As rated by Cigar Aficionado (CA) & Cigar Insider (CI)
CA Jan 20 – 90
CA Jun 19 – 90
CA Jun 13 – 88
CA Feb 12 – 88
CA Dec 08 – 91
CA Dec 07 – 89
CI Jun 07 – 89
CA Feb 05 – 88
CA Feb 04 – 89
CA Oct 02 – 90
CA Aug 00 – 88
CA Aug 98 – 89
CI Jun 97 – 88
CA Sep 96 – 89
CA Dec 17 91
CA Oct 13 93
CA Aug 13 91
CI Jul 13 93
CI Nov 11 93
CA Oct 11 94
CA Dec 09 91
CA Feb 08 97
CA Apr 07 92
CI May 06 91
CA Oct 05 91
CI Feb 04 92
CI Sep 02 91
No ratings available
CA Aug 07 – 88
CI Jun 07 – 88
CA Dec 03 – 89
CA Oct 11 – 90
CI Jun 07 – 91
CA Feb 07 – 90
CA Apr 01 – 90
CA Oct 98 – 92
CA Dec 18 – 89
CA Oct 17 – 91
CA Feb 14 – 92
CI Jun 07 – 90
CA Aug 06 – 90
CA Dec 04 – 91
CA Oct 02 – 93
CA Aug 01 – 94
CI Feb 01 – 91
CI Apr 00 – 91
CI Jul 99 – 91
CI Jun 97 – 93
CA Mar 97 – 91
CA Jun 09 – 89
CA Aug 08 – 89
CI Jun 07 – 89
CI Jun 00 – 89
CA Aug 98 – 88
CI Jul 98 – 90
CI Jun 97 – 88
CA Jan 20 – 91
CI Jun 07 86
CA Apr 07 86
CA Dec 19 – 92
CA Apr 16 – 90
CA Apr 15 – 89
CA Dec 11 – 89
CA Feb 10 – 90
CA Apr 09 – 89
CA Dec 05 – 88
CA Oct 01 – 88
CI Jun 99 – 88
CI Jun 07 – 89
CA Feb 03 – 91
CI Nov 01 – 90
CI Nov 99 – 88
CI Mar 99 – 90
CI Jul 98 – 91
CI Jun 97 – 88
CI Apr 00 90
CA Jul 24 – 91
CA Jun 12 – 89
CA Oct 10 – 89
CA Aug 05 – 89
CA Apr 04 – 89
CA Apr 03 – 90
CA Apr 02 – 89
CA Nov 21 – 91
CA Jan 21 – 91
CA Apr 17 – 93
CA Jun 15 – 91
CA Oct 08 – 91
CA Apr 06 – 91
CI Jul 04 – 91
CA Sep 23 – 90
CA Jun 17 – 90
CA Dec 15 – 91
CA Aug 14 – 92
CA Oct 13 – 90
CA Oct 12 – 93
CI Oct 15 – 89
CI Jun 18 – 89
CA Feb 16 – 89
CI Oct 15 – 89
CA Aug 18 – 88
CA Aug 17 – 89
CA Apr 16 – 89
CI Oct 15 – 89
No ratings available
CA Oct 19 – 89
CA Oct 18 – 87
CA Jun 17 – 91
CA Jul 24 – 94
CA Mar 21 – 93
CA Jul 18 – 92
CA Oct 16 – 91
CA Jun 13 – 90
CA Apr 12 – 91
CA Jun 09 – 95
CI Mar 09 – 95
CA Jun 08 – 92
CA Jun 07 – 91
CI Jan 07 – 91
CA Jan 21 – 91
CA Jun 16 – 91
CA Feb 13 – 91
CI Sep 12 – 91
CI Mar 09 – 90
CA Aug 07 – 90
CI May 05 – 90
CA Apr 00 – 90
CA Jun 99 – 91
CA Jun 98 – 91
CA May 24 – 91
CA Jan 20 – 93
CA Dec 17 – 91
CA Feb 14 – 94
CA Oct 13 – 92
CA Jan 13 – 94
CI Sep 12 – 93
CA Jun 11 – 90
CA Oct 10 – 91
CA Oct 09 – 90
CA Aug 09 – 90
CI Mar 09 – 90
CA Oct 08 – 91
CA Feb 07 – 91
CA Jun 05 – 90
CI May 05 – 93
CA Aug 03 – 92
CI Jun 01 – 92
CA Oct 00 – 93
CI Aug 99 – 93
CA Feb 99 – 92
CI Jul 98 – 92
CI Nov 97 – 90
CI Jun 97 – 91
CA Dec 19 – 93
CI Oct 19 – 93
CI Apr 17 – 90
CI Sep 12 – 91
CA Feb 12 – 94
CA Dec 11 – 94
CA Feb 10 – 91
CI Mar 09 – 92
CA Feb 06 – 93
CI May 05 – 94
CA Jun 03 – 91
CA Jun 02 – 91
CA Aug 01 – 93
CI Jun 01 – 91
CI Feb 01 – 93
CA Feb 01 – 92
CA Dec 00 – 90
CI Mar 99 – 91
CI Jun 97 – 90
CA Dec 96 – 92
CA Jan 24 – 94
CA Jan 21 – 97
CA Nov 20 – 94
CA Dec 16 – 93
CI Jun 16 – 93
CI Jun 16 – 90
CA Jul 20 – 93
CI Jul 20 – 93
CI Apr 17 – 93
CI Nov 15 – 90
CI Sept 12 – 92
CI Mar 09 – 92
CA Dec 08 – 91
CA Feb 07 – 92
CI Feb 06 – 91
CI May 05 – 93
CA Feb 05 – 90
CA Apr 03 – 93
CA Aug 02 – 92
CI Aug 99 – 93
CA Apr 14 – 90
CA Jun 13 – 90
CI Sep 12 – 90
CI Mar 09 – 90
CA Dec 07 – 91
CI May 05 – 90
CA Feb 04 – 90
CA Oct 02 – 90
CA Apr 02 – 90
CI Jun 01 – 90
CA May 21 – 94
CI May 21 – 92
CA Dec 18 – 89
CI Nov 15 – 92
CI Sept 12 – 90
CA Mar 22 – 92
CI Apr 17 – 93
CA Apr 15 – 92
CA Apr 13 – 90
CA Aug 10 – 91
CI Mar 09 – 92
CA Aug 08 – 91
CA Dec 06 – 91
CI May 05 – 91
CI Dec 04 – 92
CA Oct 01 – 90
CI Jun 01 – 93
CI Jun 98 – 90
CI Apr 19 – 91
CA Jun 15 – 92
CI Sep 12 – 91
CI Mar 09 – 93
CA Oct 06 – 90
CI May 05 – 91
CA Feb 03 – 91
CI Jun 01 – 90
CA Mar 24 – 92
CI May 21 – 92
CA Sep 20 – 91
CA Feb 02 – 90
CI Aug 99 – 91
CA Aug 98 – 90
2021 Cigar Aficionado Cigar of The Year
CA Feb 22 – 97
CA Jul 21 – 94
CA Nov 20 – 91
CI Apr 17 – 92
CA Dec 15 – 91
CA Oct 12 – 91
CI Sep 12 – 91
CA Feb 12 – 92
CA Apr 09 – 93
CI Mar 09 – 93
CI May 05 – 93
CA Dec 04 – 91
CA Jun 02 – 92
CA Dec 01 – 92
CI Jun 01 – 91
CA Jun 01 – 94
CA Jun 00 – 92
CI Mar 00 – 93
CA Aug 17 – 94
CI Apr 17 – 94
CA Feb 17 – 91
CA Feb 15 – 90
CA Dec 12 – 94
CI Sept 12 – 94
CA Feb 11 – 91
CA Oct 24 – 90
CA Jan 24 – 94
CA May 21 – 92
CA Mar 20 – 93
CA Jun 18 – 92
CA Feb 16 – 91
CA Feb 14 – 91
CI Jul 13 – 92
CA Jun 12 – 91
CI Nov 11 – 90
CA Aug 11 – 90
CA Aug 10 – 91
CI Feb 04 – 92
CA Dec 02 – 92
CI Sep 02 92
2007 Cigar Aficionado Cigar of The Year
CA Nov 23 – 92
CA May 22 – 92
CA Dec 17 – 91
CA Oct 13 – 93
CA Aug 13 – 91
CI Jul 13 – 93
CI Nov 11 – 93
CA Oct 11 – 94
CA Dec 09 – 91
CA Feb 08 – 97
CA Apr 07 – 92
CI May 06 – 91
CA Oct 05 91
CI Feb 04 92
CI Sep 02 91
CA Feb 18 – 96
CA Aug 17 – 94
CA Apr 14 – 90
CI Jul 13 – 90
CA Apr 13 – 90
CI Nov 11 – 91
CA Aug 11 – 93
CA Aug 09 – 93
CA Jun 08 – 91
CI May 06 – 92
CA Feb 06 – 91
CA Apr 04 – 90
CI Feb 04 – 92
CI Sept 02 – 93
CA Jul 23 – 92
CA Jan 20 – 95
CA Oct 19 – 92
CI Aug 19 – 92
CA Dec 14 – 91
CI Jul 13 – 92
CI Nov 11 – 91
CA Dec 10 – 92
CA Oct 09 – 91
CA Feb 09 – 90
CA Jun 07 – 90
CI May 06 – 91
CA Apr 05 – 93
CA Aug 05 – 91
CI Feb 04 – 93
CI Sept 02 – 94
CA Dec 19 – 90
CA Apr 18 – 92
CA Feb 17 – 92
CA Jun 16 – 92
CA Aug 15 – 91
CA Aug 13 – 91
CI Jul 13 – 91
CA Feb 09 – 92
CA Feb 09 – 96
CA Apr 08 – 95
CI Dec 07 – 95
2004 Cigar Aficionado Cigar of The Year
CA May 24 – 94
CA Oct 18 – 98
CA Feb 18 – 91
CA Aug 16 – 94
CA Dec 13 – 91
CI Jul 13 – 91
CI Nov 11 – 91
CA Apr 11 – 90
CI May 06 – 93
CA Feb 05 – 93
CI Jan 05 – 93
CI Oct 04 – 90
No ratings available at this time
Cigar Aficionado 2008 No. 2 “Cigar of the Year”
CA Mar 24 – 91
CA Sep 22 – 94
CA Jan 20 – 92
CA Aug 15 – 93
CA Aug 13 – 91
C1 Jul 13 – 91
CA Feb 09 – 92
CA Feb 09 – 96
CA Apr 08 – 95
C1 Dec 07 – 95
Cigar Aficionado 2016 No 5 “Cigar of the Year”
CA Feb 17 – 94
CI Aug 16 – 90
CI Aug 16 – 90 – maduro
CA Jul 23 – 93
CA Nov 20 – 98
CI Jul 20 – 95
CA Mar 20 – 95
CA Jan 19 – 95
CI Nov 18 – 93
CA Feb 15 – 92
CI Sep 14 – 92
CA Dec 11 – 95
CA Jun 11 – 90
CI May 10 – 92
CI Feb 10 – 92
2009 Cigar Aficionado Cigar of The Year
CA Nov 20 – 91
CI Jul 20 – 91
CI Jan 19 – 92
CI Nov 18 – 92
CI Sep 14 – 91
CA Feb 11 – 95
CA Apr 10 – 93
CA Feb 10 – 95
CA Dec 09 – 94
CA Sep 20 – 92
CI Jul 20 – 92
CA Feb 11 – 92
CI Oct 10 – 91
CI Oct 10 – 92
CA Mar 24 – 93
CA Mar 24 – 93
CI Nov 18 – 91
CI Sep 14 – 90
CA Feb 13 – 94
CA Aug 12 – 93
CI May 12 – 93
CA Apr 12 – 91
CI Nov 11 – 91
CA Nov 21 – 95
CI Jul 20 – 91
CI Mar 19 – 92
CA Mar 19 – 92
CI Nov 18 – 92
CI Apr 16 – 92
CA Feb 16 – 94
CA Oct 15 – 92
CI Apr 15 – 92
CA Feb 15 – 94
CI Sep 14 – 92
CI Apr 16 – 94 Natural
CI Apr 16 – 93 Maduro
CA Apr 16 – 94 Natural